Phase relations are subtopic B of Geotechnical Engineering on the FE Civil exam and the starting point for much of the rest of the area: effective stress, settlement and compaction all begin with a unit weight or a void ratio. The questions give two or three soil properties and ask for another.
The five problems below cover the conversions that come up most: water content from weights, degree of saturation, moist unit weight, specific gravity from the dry unit weight, and specific gravity from a saturated sample. Three of them use US units.
Where this sits: NCEES lists Geotechnical Engineering at 10-15 questions of the 110 on the FE Civil exam, and phase relations is subtopic B of the area. NCEES does not publish question counts below that level.
The Phase Relationships These Problems Use
The FE Reference Handbook lists these with the phase diagram; w, S and n as decimals, \( \gamma_w = 62.4 \) pcf or 9.81 kN/m3.
- Water content: \( w = W_w/W_s \), water over solids
- Saturation, voids and water: \( S\,e = w\,G_s \)
- Moist unit weight: \( \gamma = \dfrac{(G_s + S e)\,\gamma_w}{1 + e} \)
- Dry unit weight: \( \gamma_d = \dfrac{G_s\,\gamma_w}{1 + e} = \dfrac{\gamma}{1 + w} \)
- Porosity: \( n = \dfrac{e}{1 + e} \)
5 Free Soil Phase Relationship Problems
Give yourself about three minutes for each one, roughly the pace of the exam, and work it on paper before you look at the solution.
Problem 1 — Water Content from Weights
A soil sample weighs \( 95\,\mathrm{lb} \) in the wet condition and \( 85\,\mathrm{lb} \) after oven drying. What is the water content \( w \)?
Answer: B) 0.118
Step 1 – Identify given information: Wet weight \( W = 95\,\text{lb} \), dry weight \( W_s = 85\,\text{lb} \). Find water content \( w \).
Step 2 – Water content formula: From the FE Handbook: \( w = \dfrac{W_w}{W_s} \) where \( W_w = W - W_s \) is the weight of water.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$W_w = 95 - 85 = 10\,\text{lb}$$
$$w = \dfrac{10}{85} = 0.1176 \approx 0.118 = 11.8\%$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( w = 0.118 \) matches option (B). Water content is always expressed as the ratio of water weight to dry (solids) weight, not to total weight. Using total weight in the denominator gives \( 10/95 = 0.105 \), which is incorrect.
Correct answer: (B)
Problem 2 — Specific Gravity of a Saturated Sample
A saturated (no air) soil sample has wet mass = \( 186\,\mathrm{kg} \), dry mass = \( 106\,\mathrm{kg} \), and total volume = \( 0.120\,\mathrm{m}^{3} \). What is the specific gravity of soil solids \( G_s \)?
Answer: C) 2.65
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Wet mass | \( m = 186\,\text{kg} \) |
| Dry mass | \( m_s = 106\,\text{kg} \) |
| Total volume | \( V_t = 0.120\,\text{m}^3 \) |
| Condition | Saturated (\( V_a = 0 \)) |
Step 2 – Specific gravity formula: \( G_s = \dfrac{m_s}{\rho_w \, V_s} \) where \( \rho_w = 1000\,\text{kg/m}^3 \). For a saturated sample, all voids are filled with water so \( V_s = V_t - V_w \).
Step 3 – Solve:
$$m_w = 186 - 106 = 80\,\text{kg}$$
$$V_w = \dfrac{m_w}{\rho_w} = \dfrac{80}{1000} = 0.080\,\text{m}^3$$
$$V_s = V_t - V_w = 0.120 - 0.080 = 0.040\,\text{m}^3$$
$$G_s = \dfrac{106}{1000 \times 0.040} = \dfrac{106}{40} = 2.65$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( G_s = 2.65 \) matches option (C). Typical \( G_s \) values for soil solids range from 2.60 to 2.80. The saturation condition (\( V_a = 0 \)) simplifies the calculation because \( V_v = V_w \).
Correct answer: (C)
Problem 3 — Degree of Saturation
A soil has water content \( w = 18\% \), specific gravity \( G_s = 2.68 \), and void ratio \( e = 0.65 \). What is the degree of saturation \( S \)?
Answer: D) 0.74
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Water content | \( w = 18\% = 0.18 \) |
| Specific gravity | \( G_s = 2.68 \) |
| Void ratio | \( e = 0.65 \) |
Step 2 – Degree of saturation formula: From the FE Handbook: \( S = \dfrac{w \, G_s}{e} \). This relationship connects the three-phase soil properties.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$S = \dfrac{0.18 \times 2.68}{0.65} = \dfrac{0.4824}{0.65} = 0.742 \approx 74\%$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( S \approx 0.74 \) matches option (D). Degree of saturation ranges from 0 (completely dry) to 1.0 (fully saturated). A value of 74% indicates partially saturated soil.
Option (A) is \( w/e \) with the specific gravity left out; the relation on p. 266 is \( S = wG_s/e \), and the \( G_s \) is what turns a mass ratio into a volume ratio. Options (B) and (C) do not follow from the data. A degree of saturation can never exceed \( 1.0 \), which is worth checking on any answer.
Correct answer: (D)
Problem 4 — Moist Unit Weight
A soil has \( G_s = 2.65 \), void ratio \( e = 0.80 \), and degree of saturation \( S = 60\% \). Using \( \gamma_w = 62.4\,\mathrm{pcf} \), what is the moist (bulk) unit weight \( \gamma \)?
Answer: A) \( 109\,\mathrm{pcf} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Specific gravity | \( G_s = 2.65 \) |
| Void ratio | \( e = 0.80 \) |
| Degree of saturation | \( S = 60\% = 0.60 \) |
| Unit weight of water | \( \gamma_w = 62.4\,\text{pcf} \) |
Step 2 – Moist unit weight formula: From the FE Handbook: \( \gamma = \dfrac{G_s + Se}{1 + e} \cdot \gamma_w \). This general formula accounts for partial saturation.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$\gamma = \dfrac{2.65 + 0.60(0.80)}{1 + 0.80} \times 62.4 = \dfrac{2.65 + 0.48}{1.80} \times 62.4 = \dfrac{3.13}{1.80} \times 62.4 = 1.739 \times 62.4 = 108.5 \approx 109\,\text{pcf}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( \gamma \approx 109\,\text{pcf} \) matches option (A). If the soil were fully saturated (\( S = 1 \)), \( \gamma_{\text{sat}} = (2.65 + 0.80)/1.80 \times 62.4 = 119.5\,\text{pcf} \), which would be higher.
Option (C) uses \( w = Se = 0.48 \) without dividing by \( G_s \), so the water content is too large by a factor of \( 2.65 \). Option (D) is the unit weight of the grains themselves, \( G_s\gamma_w \), quoted as if it were the bulk unit weight, with the void volume never counted through \( (1+e) \). Option (B) does not follow from the data. If the soil were fully saturated, \( \gamma_{sat} = (2.65 + 0.80)/1.80 \times 62.4 = 119.5 \) pcf, so a moist unit weight has to land below that.
Correct answer: (A)
Problem 5 — Specific Gravity from the Dry Unit Weight
A soil has dry unit weight \( \gamma_d = 110\,\mathrm{pcf} \) and void ratio \( e = 0.50 \). Using \( \gamma_w = 62.4\,\mathrm{pcf} \), what is \( G_s \)?
Answer: D) 2.64
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Dry unit weight | \( \gamma_d = 110\,\text{pcf} \) |
| Void ratio | \( e = 0.50 \) |
| Unit weight of water | \( \gamma_w = 62.4\,\text{pcf} \) |
Step 2 – Rearrange dry unit weight formula for \( G_s \): Starting from \( \gamma_d = \dfrac{G_s \gamma_w}{1 + e} \), solve for \( G_s \): \( G_s = \dfrac{\gamma_d (1 + e)}{\gamma_w} \)
Step 3 – Solve:
$$G_s = \dfrac{110 \times (1 + 0.50)}{62.4} = \dfrac{110 \times 1.50}{62.4} = \dfrac{165}{62.4} = 2.644 \approx 2.64$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( G_s = 2.64 \) matches option (D). This is a typical value for soil minerals (quartz has \( G_s \approx 2.65 \)). Option (A) is \( \gamma_d/\gamma_w \) with the \( (1+e) \) forgotten, which compares the whole soil with water rather than the solids alone. Options (B) and (C) sit below the range of common soil minerals, which runs from about \( 2.6 \) to \( 2.8 \).
Correct answer: (D)
Three Mistakes That Cost Points
- Dividing by the wet weight. Water content is the weight of water over the weight of solids, not over the total. Ten pounds of water in a 95 lb sample with 85 lb of solids gives w = 0.118, not 0.105.
- Mixing up e and n. Void ratio compares voids with solids; porosity compares voids with the whole volume. For loose soils they differ a lot, and both tend to appear among the options.
- Mixing percent and decimals in Se = wGs. Enter w and S both as decimals or both as percents. Mixing them moves the answer by a factor of 100.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to draw the phase diagram for every problem?
Not every time, but it is the fastest way through a problem that mixes weights and volumes. Setting the volume of solids to 1 and filling in the diagram turns any set of given properties into plain arithmetic.
What is the difference between dry and saturated unit weight?
Dry unit weight counts only the solids per unit of total volume. Saturated unit weight adds the water that fills every void. Below the water table the effective, or buoyant, unit weight is the saturated unit weight minus the unit weight of water.
What specific gravity should I expect for soil solids?
The problem will give it or ask for it. Most soil solids fall between about 2.6 and 2.8, so a computed value far outside that range points to a units or algebra mistake.
Keep Going
Practice the rest of the area on the FE Civil geotechnical engineering practice problems page, or keep going with the lateral earth pressure problems, soil classification problems, bearing capacity problems, and consolidation settlement problems. To see these topics mixed with the other 13 areas, take the free FE Civil practice exam, or browse every topic in the free FE Civil practice problems hub.