Index properties and soil classification are subtopic A of Geotechnical Engineering on the FE Civil exam, and the numbers behind them are few: the grain sizes that set the uniformity and curvature coefficients, the void ratios behind relative density, and the fines content and plasticity that drive the AASHTO group index.
The five problems below compute each of those, including reading D10, D30 and D60 from a grain-size curve, and add one field test from subtopic C: the relative compaction of a fill.
Where this sits: NCEES lists Geotechnical Engineering at 10-15 questions of the 110 on the FE Civil exam, and the problems below come from subtopic A (index properties and soil classifications) and subtopic C (laboratory and field tests). NCEES does not publish question counts below that level.
The Index Relationships These Problems Use
The FE Reference Handbook has the USCS and AASHTO tables and these definitions; grain sizes in millimeters.
- Coefficient of uniformity: \( C_u = D_{60}/D_{10} \)
- Coefficient of curvature: \( C_c = \dfrac{D_{30}^2}{D_{10}\,D_{60}} \)
- Relative density: \( D_r = \dfrac{e_{max} - e}{e_{max} - e_{min}} \)
- AASHTO group index: \( GI = (F - 35)[0.2 + 0.005(LL - 40)] + 0.01(F - 15)(PI - 10) \)
- Relative compaction: \( RC = \gamma_{d,\,field}/\gamma_{d,\,max} \)
5 Free Soil Classification Problems
Give yourself about three minutes for each one, roughly the pace of the exam, and work it on paper before you look at the solution.
Problem 1 — Coefficient of Uniformity
A soil has \( D_{60} = 0.80\,\mathrm{mm} \) and \( D_{10} = 0.20\,\mathrm{mm} \). What is the coefficient of uniformity \( C_u \)?
Answer: D) 4
Step 1 – Identify given information: \( D_{60} = 0.80\,\text{mm} \) and \( D_{10} = 0.20\,\text{mm} \).
Step 2 – Coefficient of uniformity formula: From the FE Handbook: \( C_u = \dfrac{D_{60}}{D_{10}} \). This coefficient measures the range of particle sizes in a soil; \( C_u > 6 \) for well-graded gravel, \( C_u > 4 \) for well-graded sand.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$C_u = \dfrac{0.80}{0.20} = 4.0$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( C_u = 4.0 \) matches option (D). Since \( C_u = 4 \) for a sand, this soil barely meets the well-graded criterion for sand. Option (A) is the ratio inverted, \( D_{10}/D_{60} \); a uniformity coefficient can never fall below one, because \( D_{60} \) cannot be smaller than \( D_{10} \). Options (B) and (C) are not ratios of any two of the given sizes.
Correct answer: (D)
Problem 2 — Relative Compaction of a Fill
A fill has field dry unit weight \( \gamma_{d(field)} = 17.2\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \). The lab maximum dry unit weight is \( \gamma_{d(max)} = 18.5\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \). What is the relative compaction \( RC \), in per cent?
Answer: C) \( 93\% \)
Step 1 – Identify given information: Field dry unit weight \( \gamma_{d(\text{field})} = 17.2\,\text{kN/m}^3 \), lab maximum dry unit weight \( \gamma_{d(\max)} = 18.5\,\text{kN/m}^3 \).
Step 2 – Relative compaction formula: \( RC = \dfrac{\gamma_{d(\text{field})}}{\gamma_{d(\max)}} \times 100\% \). Most specifications require \( RC \geq 90\text{-}95\% \) for adequate compaction.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$RC = \dfrac{17.2}{18.5} \times 100 = 0.930 \times 100 = 93\%$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( RC = 93\% \) matches option (C). This soil meets a typical 90% compaction specification. Option (D) would require a field dry unit weight of \( 0.98 \times 18.5 = 18.13\,\text{kN/m}^3 \).
Correct answer: (C)
Problem 3 — Relative Density
A sand has \( e_{max} = 0.85 \), \( e_{min} = 0.45 \), and current void ratio \( e = 0.60 \). What is the relative density \( D_r \) (percent)?
Answer: B) \( 63\% \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Maximum void ratio | \( e_{\max} = 0.85 \) |
| Minimum void ratio | \( e_{\min} = 0.45 \) |
| Current void ratio | \( e = 0.60 \) |
Step 2 – Relative density formula: From the FE Handbook: \( D_r = \dfrac{e_{\max} - e}{e_{\max} - e_{\min}} \). This measures how dense a granular soil is relative to its loosest and densest possible states.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$D_r = \dfrac{0.85 - 0.60}{0.85 - 0.45} = \dfrac{0.25}{0.40} = 0.625 = 62.5\% \approx 63\%$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( D_r \approx 63\% \) matches option (B). A relative density of 63% indicates a medium-dense sand. \( D_r < 35\% \) is loose, \( 35\text{-}65\% \) is medium, and \( > 65\% \) is dense.
Option (D) is the relative compaction, the dry-unit-weight ratio \( (1+e_{\min})/(1+e) = 1.45/1.60 \), reported in place of the relative density; it drops \( e_{\max} \) from the calculation and overstates how dense the sand is. Options (A) and (C) do not follow from the data.
Correct answer: (B)
Problem 4 — AASHTO Group Index
A soil has percent passing No.200 \( F = 55 \), \( LL = 35 \), and \( PI = 12 \). What is the AASHTO group index \( GI \) (nearest integer)?
Answer: A) 4
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Percent passing No. 200 | \( F = 55 \) |
| Liquid limit | \( LL = 35 \) |
| Plasticity index | \( PI = 12 \) |
Step 2 – AASHTO Group Index formula: \( GI = (F - 35)[0.2 + 0.005(LL - 40)] + 0.01(F - 15)(PI - 10) \). Each term in brackets is taken as zero if it computes negative.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$(F - 35) = 55 - 35 = 20$$
\( (LL - 40) = 35 - 40 = -5 \), so \( 0.2 + 0.005(-5) = 0.2 - 0.025 = 0.175 \)
First term: \( 20 \times 0.175 = 3.5 \)
\( (F - 15) = 55 - 15 = 40 \), \( (PI - 10) = 12 - 10 = 2 \)
Second term: \( 0.01 \times 40 \times 2 = 0.8 \)
$$GI = 3.5 + 0.8 = 4.3 \approx 4$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( GI \approx 4 \) matches option (A). The group index is always rounded to the nearest integer and reported as a minimum of 0. Higher GI values indicate poorer subgrade quality.
Option (C) leaves the \( 35 \) per cent threshold out of the first term and multiplies the full percent passing the No. 200 sieve by the liquid-limit bracket. Options (B) and (D) do not follow from the data. The group index is always rounded to the nearest integer and reported as a minimum of \( 0 \); a higher value means a poorer subgrade.
Correct answer: (A)
Problem 5 — Cu and Cc from a Grain-Size Curve
Sieve results (percent passing): 4.75mm 100, 2.0mm 92, 0.85mm 70, 0.425mm 52, 0.25mm 40, 0.15mm 28, 0.075mm 12, 0.05mm 5. From the semi-log grain-size curve, estimate \( D_{10} \), \( D_{30} \), \( D_{60} \) (log interpolation) and compute \( C_u \) and \( C_c \). Which pair is closest?
Answer: A) \( C_u = 8.7 \) and \( C_c = 0.69 \)
Step 1 – Identify given information: Sieve analysis data (percent passing at various sieve sizes). Read \( D_{10} \), \( D_{30} \), \( D_{60} \) from the semi-log grain-size distribution curve.
Step 2 – Gradation coefficient formulas: From the FE Handbook: \( C_u = \dfrac{D_{60}}{D_{10}} \) and \( C_c = \dfrac{D_{30}^2}{D_{10} \times D_{60}} \)
Step 3 – Solve:
From interpolation on the curve: \( D_{10} \approx 0.067\,\text{mm} \), \( D_{30} \approx 0.163\,\text{mm} \), \( D_{60} \approx 0.578\,\text{mm} \)
$$C_u = \dfrac{0.578}{0.067} \approx 8.7$$
$$C_c = \dfrac{(0.163)^2}{0.067 \times 0.578} = \dfrac{0.02657}{0.03873} \approx 0.69$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( C_u \approx 8.7 \) and \( C_c \approx 0.69 \) match option (A). Since \( C_u > 6 \) but \( C_c < 1 \) (needs \( 1 \leq C_c \leq 3 \) for well-graded), this soil is poorly graded despite having a wide range of particle sizes.
Option (C) is close to what LINEAR interpolation between the bracketing sieve sizes gives in place of interpolation on the log scale: it inflates \( D_{60} \) more than \( D_{10} \), pushes \( C_u \) up and makes the soil look well graded. Option (B) keeps the right \( C_u \) with a \( C_c \) inside the well-graded band, and option D does not follow from the data.
Correct answer: (A)
Three Mistakes That Cost Points
- Interpolating grain sizes on a linear scale. The grain-size curve is plotted against the logarithm of particle size, so D10, D30 and D60 have to be interpolated on log D. Linear interpolation between sieve sizes gives a noticeably different Cc.
- Swapping D10 and D60. Cu is never less than 1: the larger diameter goes on top. A result below 1 means the two were reversed.
- Measuring relative density from the wrong end. \( D_r \) measures how close the soil is to its densest state, so the numerator is \( e_{max} - e \). Using \( e - e_{min} \) gives its complement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a sand well graded?
In the USCS a sand is well graded when Cu is at least 6 and Cc is between 1 and 3; for a gravel the limit on Cu is 4. Failing either test makes the soil poorly graded.
What does a high AASHTO group index mean?
A poorer subgrade. The group index grows with the fines content and the plasticity of the soil; 0 marks a good subgrade material and values of 20 or more a very poor one.
Is relative compaction the same as relative density?
No. Relative compaction compares the field dry unit weight with the laboratory maximum from a Proctor test and is used to accept a fill. Relative density compares void ratios and describes how dense a granular soil is between its loosest and densest states.
Keep Going
Practice the rest of the area on the FE Civil geotechnical engineering practice problems page, or keep going with the lateral earth pressure problems, soil phase relationship problems, bearing capacity problems, and consolidation settlement problems. To see these topics mixed with the other 13 areas, take the free FE Civil practice exam, or browse every topic in the free FE Civil practice problems hub.