Stability of retaining structures is subtopic E of Geotechnical Engineering on the FE Civil exam, and almost every item starts with the lateral pressure on the wall: active when the wall moves away from the soil, passive when it is pushed into it, and at rest when it cannot move at all.
The five problems below build the pressure diagram step by step: a plain Rankine active thrust, the same kind of wall with a surcharge, an at-rest wall, a wall with a water table in the backfill, and the resultant of a braced-cut pressure diagram.
Where this sits: NCEES lists Geotechnical Engineering at 10-15 questions of the 110 on the FE Civil exam, and stability of retaining structures (e.g., active/passive/at-rest pressure) is subtopic E of the area. NCEES does not publish question counts below that level.
The Pressure Relationships These Problems Use
The FE Reference Handbook gives the Rankine coefficients and the pressure diagrams; these forms apply to a smooth vertical wall with level backfill.
- Rankine coefficients: \( K_a = \tan^2(45^\circ - \phi/2) \) and \( K_p = \tan^2(45^\circ + \phi/2) \)
- At rest (Jaky): \( K_0 = 1 - \sin\phi \)
- Pressure at depth z: \( \sigma_h = K\,\sigma'_v + u \), with \( \sigma'_v = \gamma z \) above the water table
- Triangular diagram: \( P = \tfrac12 K\gamma H^2 \), acting at \( H/3 \) above the base
- Uniform surcharge q: a rectangle of pressure \( Kq \) over the full height, acting at \( H/2 \)
5 Free Lateral Earth Pressure Problems
Give yourself about three minutes for each one, roughly the pace of the exam, and work it on paper before you look at the solution.
Problem 1 — Rankine Active Thrust
A vertical smooth wall retains level granular backfill of height \( H = 4\,\mathrm{m} \). Soil unit weight \( \gamma = 18\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \) and \( \phi = 30^\circ \). Using Rankine active pressure, what is the total active thrust \( P_a \) (\( \mathrm{kN/m} \) of wall)?
Answer: D) \( 48\,\mathrm{kN/m} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Wall height | \( H = 4\,\text{m} \) |
| Unit weight | \( \gamma = 18\,\text{kN/m}^3 \) |
| Friction angle | \( \phi = 30^\circ \) (so \( K_a = 0.333 \)) |
Step 2 – Rankine active thrust formula: For cohesionless soil: \( P_a = \dfrac{1}{2} K_a \gamma H^2 \). This is the resultant of the triangular pressure distribution.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$P_a = \dfrac{1}{2}(0.333)(18)(4)^2 = 0.5 \times 0.333 \times 18 \times 16 = 48\,\text{kN/m}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( P_a = 48\,\text{kN/m} \) matches option (D). Option (A) leaves the height unsquared, \( \tfrac12 K_a \gamma H \) instead of \( \tfrac12 K_a \gamma H^2 \), and it is a pressure in kPa rather than a force per metre. Option (B) would result from using \( K_a = 0.25 \), which is incorrect for \( \phi = 30^\circ \). Option (C) does not follow from the data. This resultant acts at \( H/3 = 1.33 \) m above the base.
Correct answer: (D)
Problem 2 — At-Rest Thrust on a Rigid Wall
A rigid wall (at-rest) retains \( H = 5.0\,\mathrm{m} \) of sand with \( \phi = 34^\circ \) and \( \gamma = 19\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \). Using Jaky \( K_0 \), what is the total at-rest thrust \( P_0 \) (\( \mathrm{kN/m} \))?
Answer: C) \( 105\,\mathrm{kN/m} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Wall height | \( H = 5.0\,\text{m} \) |
| Friction angle | \( \phi = 34^\circ \) (\( K_0 = 0.441 \)) |
| Unit weight | \( \gamma = 19\,\text{kN/m}^3 \) |
Step 2 – At-rest thrust formula: \( P_0 = \dfrac{1}{2} K_0 \gamma H^2 \). The pressure distribution is triangular, just like the active case but with a larger coefficient.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$P_0 = \dfrac{1}{2}(0.441)(19)(5.0)^2 = 0.5 \times 0.441 \times 19 \times 25 = 104.7 \approx 105\,\text{kN/m}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( P_0 \approx 105\,\text{kN/m} \) matches option (C). This is about 33% higher than the active thrust for the same geometry, reflecting the higher lateral stress when no wall movement is permitted.
Correct answer: (C)
Problem 3 — Active Thrust with a Surcharge
A smooth vertical wall retains \( H = 5\,\mathrm{m} \) of level granular backfill with \( \gamma = 19\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \), \( \phi = 32^\circ \) and \( c = 0 \). A uniform surcharge \( q = 12\,\mathrm{kPa} \) acts over the whole backfill surface, and the water table is below the base of the wall. Using Rankine active pressure, what is the total active thrust \( P_A \) on the wall, in \( \mathrm{kN} \) per meter of wall?
Answer: C) \( 91\,\mathrm{kN/m} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Retained height | \( H = 5\,\text{m} \) |
| Unit weight | \( \gamma = 19\,\text{kN/m}^3 \) |
| Friction angle, cohesion | \( \phi = 32^\circ \), \( c = 0 \) |
| Surcharge | \( q = 12\,\text{kPa} \) |
| Water table | below the base (no pore pressure) |
Step 2 – Handbook equations (p. 269): For a smooth wall with level backfill and \( c = 0 \), \( K_A = \tan^2(45^\circ - \phi/2) \). A layer of height \( H \) whose effective vertical stress is \( \sigma'_1 \) at its top and \( \sigma'_2 \) at its base pushes on the wall with \( P_A = \sigma'_1 K_A H + \tfrac12(\sigma'_2 - \sigma'_1)K_A H \). The surcharge makes the vertical stress at the surface \( \sigma'_1 = q \) instead of zero, so the pressure diagram is a rectangle (first term) plus a triangle (second term).
Step 3 – Solve:
$$K_A = \tan^2\!\left(45^\circ - \dfrac{32^\circ}{2}\right) = \tan^2 29^\circ = 0.3073$$
The effective vertical stress is \( \sigma'_1 = q = 12\,\text{kPa} \) at the surface and \( \sigma'_2 = q + \gamma H = 12 + 19(5) = 107\,\text{kPa} \) at the base, so:
$$P_A = 12(0.3073)(5) + \tfrac12(107 - 12)(0.3073)(5)$$
The first term, the rectangle, is \( 18.4\,\text{kN/m} \) and the second, the triangle, is \( 73.0\,\text{kN/m} \):
$$P_A = 18.4 + 73.0 = 91.4\,\text{kN/m}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( P_A \approx 91\,\text{kN/m} \) matches option (C). Option (A), \( 73 \), is the soil triangle alone, \( \tfrac12 K_A \gamma H^2 \), with the surcharge left out. Option (B), \( 82 \), takes the surcharge pressure as a triangle, \( \tfrac12 K_A q H = 9.2 \), when it is constant with depth and gives \( K_A q H = 18.4 \). Option (D), \( 133 \), adds the surcharge as \( qH = 60 \) without multiplying by \( K_A \).
Correct answer: (C)
Problem 4 — Resultant of a Braced-Cut Diagram
For a braced cut in sand, assume the apparent lateral earth pressure diagram is TRIANGULAR, increasing linearly from zero at the ground surface to a maximum at the bottom of excavation. If \( H = 21\,\mathrm{ft} \), at what distance above the bottom does the resultant lateral force act?
Answer: B) \( 7.0\,\mathrm{ft} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information: Triangular lateral pressure distribution (zero at top, maximum at bottom), \( H = 21\,\text{ft} \).
Step 2 – Resultant location for triangular distribution: The centroid of a triangle is at \( 1/3 \) of the height from the base (the wide end). This is a fundamental property from statics.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$y = \dfrac{H}{3} = \dfrac{21}{3} = 7\,\text{ft above bottom}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( y = 7\,\text{ft} \) matches option (B). Option (C) 10.5 ft is \( H/2 \), which would apply to a uniform (rectangular) pressure distribution. Option (D) 14.0 ft is \( 2H/3 \), which is the centroid measured from the top.
Correct answer: (B)
Problem 5 — Wall with a Water Table
A wall retains \( H = 6\,\mathrm{m} \) of sand with \( \phi = 30^\circ \). The water table is \( 2\,\mathrm{m} \) below the backfill surface. Use \( \gamma \) (above WT) = \( 18\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \), \( \gamma_{sat} \) (below WT) = \( 20\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \), and \( \gamma_w = 9.81\,\mathrm{kN/m}^{3} \). Using Rankine active for effective stress plus hydrostatic water pressure, what is the total lateral force on the wall (\( \mathrm{kN/m} \))?
Answer: D) \( 166\,\mathrm{kN/m} \)
Step 1 – Compute the Rankine active earth pressure coefficient:
$$ K_a = \tan^2\!\left(45^\circ - \frac{\phi}{2}\right) = \tan^2(30^\circ) = \left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\right)^2 = \frac{1}{3} = 0.333 $$
Step 2 – Compute effective vertical stress \( \sigma'_v \) at key depths:
The wall has two zones: dry above the water table (0–2 m) and saturated below (2–6 m).
| Depth \( z \) | \( \sigma'_v \) (kPa) | \( \sigma'_a = K_a \sigma'_v \) | \( u \) (kPa) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 m | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 2 m | \( 18(2) = 36 \) | \( 0.333(36) = 12 \) | 0 |
| 6 m | \( 36 + (20-9.81)(4) = 76.76 \) | \( 0.333(76.76) = 25.58 \) | \( 9.81(4) = 39.24 \) |
Step 3 – Compute effective lateral earth pressure force:
The pressure diagram has a triangle (0–2 m) plus a trapezoid (2–6 m):
$$ P'_a = \tfrac{1}{2}(12)(2) + (12)(4) + \tfrac{1}{2}(25.58-12)(4) $$
$$ P'_a = 12 + 48 + 27.16 = 87.16 \,\mathrm{kN/m} $$
Step 4 – Compute hydrostatic water pressure force:
Triangular water pressure from \( z = 2 \) to \( z = 6 \):
$$ P_w = \frac{1}{2} \gamma_w h_w^2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.81)(4)^2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.81)(16) = 78.48 \,\mathrm{kN/m} $$
Step 5 – Total lateral force:
$$ P_{\text{total}} = P'_a + P_w = 87.16 + 78.48 = 165.64 \approx 166 \,\mathrm{kN/m} $$
Option (A) is the effective soil thrust alone, with the \( 78.5 \) kN/m of water pressure forgotten; below the water table the water pushes on the wall in full, with no \( K_a \) on it, and here it is almost half of the total. Options (B) and (C) do not follow from the data.
Correct answer: (D)
Three Mistakes That Cost Points
- Multiplying the water pressure by K. Below the water table only the effective stress is multiplied by K; the pore pressure \( u = \gamma_w h \) acts on the wall in full. Multiplying it by \( K_a \) cuts the water force to about a third.
- Using the total unit weight below the water table. The effective stress grows with \( \gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_w \) below the water table. Using \( \gamma_{sat} \) there and then adding u counts the water twice.
- Placing every resultant at H/3. Only the triangular part acts at one third of the height. A surcharge rectangle acts at mid-height, so the total thrust sits higher than H/3 whenever there is a surcharge.
Frequently Asked Questions
When do I use active, passive or at-rest pressure?
Active when the wall can yield away from the soil, as most cantilever and gravity walls do; passive for the soil in front of the wall that resists it; at rest for walls that cannot move, such as basement walls held by the floors.
Does Rankine theory include wall friction?
No. Rankine assumes a smooth vertical wall, which is why the problems state it. Coulomb's method includes wall friction and a sloping backfill; use it when the problem gives a wall friction angle.
Why is a braced-cut diagram different from a Rankine triangle?
The struts hold the wall near the top, so the pressure redistributes toward an apparent envelope instead of growing linearly with depth. The problem states the shape to use; for a triangle the resultant acts at one third of the height.
Keep Going
Practice the rest of the area on the FE Civil geotechnical engineering practice problems page, or keep going with the soil phase relationship problems, soil classification problems, bearing capacity problems, and consolidation settlement problems. To see these topics mixed with the other 13 areas, take the free FE Civil practice exam, or browse every topic in the free FE Civil practice problems hub.