Consolidation and differential settlement is subtopic I of Geotechnical Engineering on the FE Civil exam. Most items ask for the primary consolidation settlement of a clay layer, and the first decision is whether the clay is normally consolidated or overconsolidated, because that decides which index you use.
The four problems below cover a normally consolidated clay in SI units and another in US units, an overconsolidated clay that stays below its preconsolidation stress, and the immediate settlement of a footing on an elastic soil.
Where this sits: NCEES lists Geotechnical Engineering at 10-15 questions of the 110 on the FE Civil exam, and consolidation and differential settlement is subtopic I of the area. NCEES does not publish question counts below that level.
The Settlement Relationships These Problems Use
The FE Reference Handbook gives these for a clay layer of thickness H, with the stresses taken at its mid-depth.
- Normally consolidated: \( S = \dfrac{C_c H}{1 + e_0}\log_{10}\dfrac{\sigma'_0 + \Delta\sigma}{\sigma'_0} \)
- Overconsolidated, final stress below \( \sigma'_p \): the same form with \( C_r \) in place of \( C_c \)
- Overconsolidated, final stress above \( \sigma'_p \): recompression with \( C_r \) up to \( \sigma'_p \), then compression with \( C_c \) beyond it
- Immediate (elastic) settlement: \( S = \dfrac{q B (1 - \nu^2) I_s}{E_s} \)
4 Free Consolidation Settlement Problems
Give yourself about three minutes for each one, roughly the pace of the exam, and work it on paper before you look at the solution.
Problem 1 — Normally Consolidated Clay in SI Units
A \( 4.0\,\mathrm{m} \) thick normally consolidated clay layer has \( C_c = 0.30 \) and initial void ratio \( e_0 = 0.90 \). The initial effective vertical stress at the layer midpoint is \( \sigma'_i = 100\,\mathrm{kPa} \). A foundation increases stress at the midpoint by \( \Delta\sigma = 50\,\mathrm{kPa} \) (so \( \sigma'_f = 150\,\mathrm{kPa} \)). Estimate primary consolidation settlement using \( S = (C_c/(1+e_0)) H \log_{10}(\sigma'_f/\sigma'_i) \).
Answer: A) \( 110\,\mathrm{mm} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Clay layer thickness | \( H = 4.0\,\text{m} \) |
| Compression index | \( C_c = 0.30 \) |
| Initial void ratio | \( e_0 = 0.90 \) |
| Initial effective stress | \( \sigma'_i = 100\,\text{kPa} \) |
| Final effective stress | \( \sigma'_f = 150\,\text{kPa} \) |
Step 2 – Primary consolidation settlement formula: From the FE Handbook: \( S = \dfrac{C_c}{1 + e_0} H \log_{10}\!\left(\dfrac{\sigma'_f}{\sigma'_i}\right) \) (normally consolidated clay).
Step 3 – Solve:
$$S = \dfrac{0.30}{1 + 0.90} \times 4.0 \times \log_{10}\!\left(\dfrac{150}{100}\right) = 0.1579 \times 4.0 \times 0.1761 = 0.1112\,\text{m} = 111\,\text{mm}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( S \approx 111\,\text{mm} \) matches option (A). This is a significant settlement that occurs over time as pore water drains. The stress ratio of 1.5 produces a \( \log_{10} \) value of only 0.176, but the relatively large \( C_c \) and thick layer amplify the settlement.
Option (B) is what a linearised compression curve gives, using the coefficient of compressibility at the initial stress in place of the \( \log_{10} \) stress ratio, and it overestimates by about \( 23 \) per cent. Option (D) drops the \( (1+e_0) \) from the denominator. Option (C) does not follow from the data. The stress ratio of \( 1.5 \) produces a \( \log_{10} \) value of only \( 0.176 \), but the relatively large \( C_c \) and thick layer amplify the settlement, which develops over time as pore water drains.
Correct answer: (A)
Problem 2 — Normally Consolidated Clay in US Units
A \( 10 \) ft thick layer of normally consolidated clay has \( e_0 = 0.85 \) and \( C_c = 0.25 \). The initial effective stress at the middle of the layer is \( 2{,}000 \) psf, and a new fill adds \( 1{,}500 \) psf. What is the ultimate primary consolidation settlement most nearly?
Answer: B) \( 3.9\,\mathrm{in} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information: \( H_S = 10 \) ft, \( e_0 = 0.85 \), \( C_c = 0.25 \), \( \sigma'_0 = 2{,}000 \) psf, \( \Delta\sigma = 1{,}500 \) psf so \( \sigma'_f = 3{,}500 \) psf.
Step 2 – Normally consolidated, so the whole increment is virgin compression (FE Handbook, p. 267): \( S_{ULT} = \dfrac{C_c H_S}{1+e_0}\log_{10}\dfrac{\sigma'_f}{\sigma'_0} \). The logarithm is base ten, and its argument is the ratio of the FINAL stress to the initial one, not of the increment to the initial one.
Step 3 – Solve:
$$S_{ULT} = \dfrac{0.25(10)}{1.85}\log_{10}\dfrac{3{,}500}{2{,}000} = 1.351\log_{10}(1.75) = 1.351(0.2430) = 0.328\,\text{ft} = 3.9\,\text{in}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( S_{ULT} \approx 3.9 \) in matches option (B). Option (C) \( 7.3 \) in drops the \( (1+e_0) \) from the denominator. Option (D) \( 9.1 \) in uses the natural logarithm in place of \( \log_{10} \), which is \( 2.3 \) times larger. Option (A) \( 2.0 \) in puts \( \Delta\sigma/\sigma'_0 \) inside the logarithm instead of \( \sigma'_f/\sigma'_0 \). Note that the settlement is evaluated at the MIDDLE of the layer, where the stresses are given, and that this is the ultimate value reached only when consolidation is complete.
Correct answer: (B)
Problem 3 — Immediate Settlement of a Strip Footing
Estimate immediate (elastic) settlement of a flexible strip footing using \( S = q B (1-\nu^2) I_s / E_s \). Given: \( q = 200\,\mathrm{kPa} \), \( B = 2.0\,\mathrm{m} \), \( \nu = 0.30 \), \( E_s = 30\,\mathrm{MPa} \), \( I_s = 1.1 \). What is \( S \)?
Answer: B) \( 13\,\mathrm{mm} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information:
| Contact pressure | \( q = 200\,\text{kPa} \) |
| Footing width | \( B = 2.0\,\text{m} \) |
| Poisson ratio | \( \nu = 0.30 \) |
| Elastic modulus | \( E_s = 30\,\text{MPa} = 30{,}000\,\text{kPa} \) |
| Influence factor | \( I_s = 1.1 \) |
Step 2 – Elastic (immediate) settlement formula: \( S = \dfrac{q B (1 - \nu^2) I_s}{E_s} \)
Step 3 – Solve:
$$S = \dfrac{200 \times 2.0 \times (1 - 0.30^2) \times 1.1}{30{,}000} = \dfrac{200 \times 2.0 \times 0.91 \times 1.1}{30{,}000} = \dfrac{400.4}{30{,}000} = 0.01335\,\text{m} = 13.35 \approx 13\,\text{mm}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( S \approx 13\,\text{mm} \) matches option (B). Immediate settlement occurs in both granular and cohesive soils but is often the dominant settlement component for sands (where consolidation settlement is small).
Option (C) leaves the \( (1-\nu^2) \) factor out of the elastic settlement formula, so the settlement comes out about \( 10 \) per cent too large. Options (A) and (D) do not follow from the data. Immediate settlement occurs in both granular and cohesive soils but is often the dominant component for sands, where consolidation settlement is small.
Correct answer: (B)
Problem 4 — Overconsolidated Clay
An \( 8 \) ft thick clay layer has \( e_0 = 0.90 \), \( C_c = 0.30 \), an initial effective stress of \( 1{,}500 \) psf at mid-depth and a past maximum (preconsolidation) stress of \( 3{,}000 \) psf. A structure adds \( 1{,}000 \) psf at mid-depth. Taking the recompression index from the FE Handbook correlation \( C_R = C_c/6 \), what is the ultimate consolidation settlement?
Answer: A) \( 0.56\,\mathrm{in} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information: \( H_S = 8 \) ft, \( e_0 = 0.90 \), \( C_c = 0.30 \), \( \sigma'_0 = 1{,}500 \) psf, \( \sigma'_c = 3{,}000 \) psf, \( \sigma'_f = 2{,}500 \) psf.
Step 2 – Decide which case on p. 267 applies: the final stress \( 2{,}500 \) psf is still BELOW the past maximum of \( 3{,}000 \) psf, so the clay stays on its recompression branch and only \( C_R \) is used. The correlation gives \( C_R = C_c/6 = 0.05 \).
Step 3 – Solve:
$$S_{ULT} = \dfrac{C_R H_S}{1+e_0}\log_{10}\dfrac{\sigma'_f}{\sigma'_0} = \dfrac{0.05(8)}{1.90}\log_{10}\dfrac{2{,}500}{1{,}500} = 0.2105(0.2218) = 0.0467\,\text{ft} = 0.56\,\text{in}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \( S_{ULT} \approx 0.56 \) in matches option (A). Option (D) \( 3.36 \) in uses \( C_c \) throughout, treating the overconsolidated clay as if it were normally consolidated, and it is six times too large. Option (C) \( 1.06 \) in drops the \( (1+e_0) \). Option (B) \( 0.76 \) in takes the logarithm to the preconsolidation stress, \( \log(3{,}000/1{,}500) \), as though the load had reached it. Recompression is stiff, which is why an overconsolidated clay settles so much less than a normally consolidated one under the same load, and why the comparison of \( \sigma'_f \) with \( \sigma'_c \) has to be made before any settlement is computed.
Correct answer: (A)
Three Mistakes That Cost Points
- Using Cc on an overconsolidated clay. When the final stress stays below the preconsolidation stress the soil only recompresses, so use \( C_r \), several times smaller than \( C_c \). Using \( C_c \) overstates the settlement by that factor.
- Leaving H in feet when the answer is in inches. The settlement comes out in the units of H. An 8 ft layer gives feet; multiply by 12, or start with H = 96 in.
- Taking the stresses at the top of the layer. Use the effective stress and the stress increase at mid-depth of the clay, which stand for the layer as a whole. Values at the top give a larger stress ratio and overstate the settlement.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if a clay is overconsolidated?
Compare its preconsolidation stress with the current effective stress. If the preconsolidation stress is larger, the clay carried more load in the past and is overconsolidated; the ratio of the two is the overconsolidation ratio.
Is immediate settlement the same as consolidation settlement?
No. Immediate settlement happens as the load is applied, from elastic distortion of the soil. Primary consolidation develops over time as water drains out of a saturated clay, and for clays it is usually the larger part.
What if the problem gives no compression index?
It will give a way to get one, such as a correlation with the liquid limit, or the recompression index as a fraction of the compression index, as the overconsolidated problem on this page does.
Keep Going
Practice the rest of the area on the FE Civil geotechnical engineering practice problems page, or keep going with the lateral earth pressure problems, soil phase relationship problems, soil classification problems, and bearing capacity problems. To see these topics mixed with the other 13 areas, take the free FE Civil practice exam, or browse every topic in the free FE Civil practice problems hub.