Column analysis is subtopic C of Structural Engineering on the FE Civil exam, and its core is the Euler buckling load: how the critical load depends on stiffness, length and the way the ends are held. The questions are short, but they turn on two things that are easy to get wrong, the effective length factor K and the units of length.
The five problems below, all in US units, go from the radius of gyration to the critical load of a pinned column and a cantilever column, the moment of inertia a target load needs, and the critical stress at a given slenderness.
Where this sits: NCEES lists Structural Engineering at 10-15 questions of the 110 on the FE Civil exam, and column analysis (e.g., buckling, boundary conditions) is subtopic C of the area. NCEES does not publish question counts below that level.
The Buckling Relationships These Problems Use
The FE Reference Handbook gives the Euler formula and the effective length factors; these are the relationships the problems use, with E in ksi, I in in4 and lengths in inches.
- Euler critical load: \( P_{cr} = \dfrac{\pi^2 EI}{(KL)^2} \)
- Critical stress: \( \sigma_{cr} = \dfrac{\pi^2 E}{(KL/r)^2} \)
- Radius of gyration: \( r = \sqrt{I/A} \)
- Theoretical K: pinned-pinned 1.0, fixed-free 2.0, fixed-pinned 0.7, fixed-fixed 0.5
5 Free Column Buckling Problems
Give yourself about three minutes for each one, roughly the pace of the exam, and work it on paper before you look at the solution.
Problem 1 — Radius of Gyration
A column cross section has area \( A = 60\,\mathrm{in}^{2} \) and moment of inertia \( I = 900\,\mathrm{in}^{4} \) about the weak axis. The radius of gyration \( r \) about that axis is most nearly:
Answer: B) \( 3.9\,\mathrm{in} \)
Step 1 – Identify given information: \(A = 60\,\text{in}^2\), \(I = 900\,\text{in}^4\) (about the weak axis).
Step 2 – Radius of gyration formula:
$$r = \sqrt{\dfrac{I}{A}}$$
Step 3 – Substitute and solve:
$$r = \sqrt{\dfrac{900}{60}} = \sqrt{15} \approx 3.87\,\text{in}$$
Step 4 – Answer: \(r \approx 3.9\,\text{in}\), matching option (B). The radius of gyration is a geometric property that relates \(I\) and \(A\). It is used to compute the slenderness ratio \(KL/r\) for column buckling calculations.
Correct answer: (B)
Problem 2 — Critical Stress at KL/r = 120
A long steel column has effective slenderness ratio \( KL/r = 120 \) and \( E = 29{,}000\,\mathrm{ksi} \). The Euler critical buckling stress \( \sigma_{cr} \) is most nearly:
Answer: A) \( 20\,\mathrm{ksi} \)
Step 1 – Use the stress form of Euler:
\( \sigma_{cr} = F_e = \dfrac{\pi^2E}{(KL/r)^2} \). This is the same equation as \( P_{cr} = \pi^2EI/(KL)^2 \) divided through by the area, using \( I = Ar^2 \).
Step 2 – Solve:
$$\sigma_{cr} = \dfrac{286{,}218}{(120)^2} = \dfrac{286{,}218}{14{,}400} = 19.9\,\text{ksi}$$
Step 3 – Answer:
\( \sigma_{cr} \approx 20\,\text{ksi} \).
The other three options can be rejected on physics rather than arithmetic. A structural steel has \( F_y = 36 \) or \( 50\,\text{ksi} \), and a column can never reach a buckling stress above its own yield stress, so (B) \( 45 \), (C) \( 80 \) and (D) \( 120\,\text{ksi} \) are impossible answers for a steel column of any slenderness.
The reverse of that observation is the useful one. At \( KL/r = 120 \) the Euler stress is only \( 20\,\text{ksi} \), well under \( F_y \), so this column really does buckle elastically and Euler applies. It is at LOW slenderness that Euler stops being true, which is what the two branches on p. 287 exist to handle.
Correct answer: (A)
Problem 3 — Euler Load of a Cantilever Column
A steel cantilever column (fixed–free) has \( L = 10\,\mathrm{ft} \), \( E = 29{,}000\,\mathrm{ksi} \), and \( I = 180\,\mathrm{in}^{4} \). Using Euler buckling, \( P_{cr} \) is most nearly:
Answer: D) \( 890\,\mathrm{kips} \)
Step 1 – Get the effective length factor first:
A cantilever column, fixed at the base and free at the top, has \( K = 2.0 \). It is the worst of the ideal cases, because the free end can sway.
Step 2 – Euler buckling load:
\( P_{cr} = \dfrac{\pi^2EI}{(KL)^2} \), with \( KL = 2.0(120) = 240\,\text{in} \).
Step 3 – Solve:
$$P_{cr} = \dfrac{286{,}218(180)}{(240)^2} = \dfrac{51{,}519{,}240}{57{,}600} = 894\,\text{kips}$$
Step 4 – Answer:
\( P_{cr} \approx 890\,\text{kips} \).
(A) \( 220 \) is a quarter of the answer, which is what applying the factor \( K \) a SECOND time produces, that is using \( KL = 480\,\text{in} \).
(B) \( 450 \) and (C) \( 780 \) follow from no route.
Notice what is NOT on the list: ignoring \( K \) altogether would give \( 3{,}580\,\text{kips} \), four times the answer, and no option is anywhere near it. When every option is small compared with the bare \( \pi^2EI/L^2 \), the question is telling you that the end conditions matter.
Correct answer: (D)
Problem 4 — Moment of Inertia for a Target Load
A pinned–pinned steel column (\( K = 1.0 \)) is \( 15\,\mathrm{ft} \) long with \( E = 29{,}000\,\mathrm{ksi} \). If the desired Euler critical load is \( P_{cr} = 1{,}200\,\mathrm{kips} \), the required moment of inertia \( I \) about the buckling axis is most nearly:
Answer: D) \( 136\,\mathrm{in}^{4} \)
Step 1 – Rearrange Euler for the unknown:
\( P_{cr} = \dfrac{\pi^2EI}{(KL)^2} \), so \( I = \dfrac{P_{cr}(KL)^2}{\pi^2E} \).
Step 2 – Substitute in inches:
\( K = 1.0 \) and \( L = 15\,\text{ft} = 180\,\text{in} \), so \( KL = 180\,\text{in} \) and \( (KL)^2 = 32{,}400\,\text{in}^2 \).
Step 3 – Solve:
$$I = \dfrac{1{,}200(32{,}400)}{286{,}218} = \dfrac{38{,}880{,}000}{286{,}218} = 136\,\text{in}^4$$
Step 4 – Answer:
\( I \approx 136\,\text{in}^4 \).
(B) \( 67 \) is what taking \( K = 0.7 \) gives, the fixed-pinned factor applied to a column the problem says is pinned at both ends; since \( I \) goes with \( K^2 \), that halves the requirement.
(A) \( 55 \) and (C) \( 95 \) follow from no route.
Design questions in this direction are worth recognising by their shape: the required stiffness grows with the SQUARE of the unbraced length, so a column two storeys tall needs four times the moment of inertia of the same column braced at mid-height.
Correct answer: (D)
Problem 5 — Euler Load of a Pinned Column
A pin-pin steel column has unbraced length \( L = 12\,\mathrm{ft} \), \( E = 29{,}000\,\mathrm{ksi} \), \( I = 200\,\mathrm{in}^{4} \). Use Euler \( P_{cr} = \pi^2 EI/(KL)^2 \). Take \( K = 1.0 \). What is \( P_{cr} \) (\( \mathrm{kips} \))?
Answer: B) 2760
Step 1 – Identify given information:
\( K = 1.0 \), \( L = 12\,\text{ft} = 144\,\text{in} \), \( E = 29{,}000\,\text{ksi} \), \( I = 200\,\text{in}^4 \).
Step 2 – Euler buckling load:
$$P_{cr} = \dfrac{\pi^2EI}{(KL)^2} = \dfrac{286{,}218(200)}{(144)^2}$$
Step 3 – Solve:
$$P_{cr} = \dfrac{57{,}243{,}600}{20{,}736} = 2{,}761\,\text{kips}$$
Step 4 – Answer:
\( P_{cr} \approx 2{,}760\,\text{kips} \).
(D) \( 5{,}600 \) is close to what taking \( K = 0.7 \) gives, \( 5{,}630\,\text{kips} \), and it is on the list because reaching for the fixed-pinned factor when the problem says pin-pin doubles the answer.
(C) \( 4{,}200 \) is near the value for \( K = 0.8 \), and (A) \( 2{,}400 \) follows from no route.
Read \( K \) off the problem statement before anything else. It enters squared, so an error in it is worth a factor of two or four while an error in \( I \) is worth only its own ratio.
Correct answer: (B)
Three Mistakes That Cost Points
- Leaving the length in feet. With E in ksi and I in in4, KL must be in inches: 12 ft is 144 in. Squaring a length left in feet makes the critical load 144 times too large.
- Forgetting K for a cantilever. A fixed-free column buckles like a pinned column twice as long, so KL = 2L and its critical load is a quarter of the pinned value for the same section and length.
- Using the strong-axis moment of inertia. A column buckles about the axis with the smaller I, or the larger KL/r when the bracing differs by axis. Check both before you pick one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Euler buckling enough for steel column design on the FE exam?
Euler gives the elastic critical load and holds for long, slender columns. Steel design questions use the AISC column strength equations, which stay below the Euler value because of initial crookedness and yielding; the problems on this page stay with the elastic case.
What does the slenderness ratio tell you?
KL/r compares the effective length with the radius of gyration of the section. The critical stress falls with its square, so doubling the slenderness cuts the buckling stress to a quarter.
Which K should I use, theoretical or recommended?
Use what the problem states. Design tables list a theoretical value and a slightly larger recommended value for each end condition; a problem that names an ideal end condition expects the theoretical one.
Keep Going
Practice the rest of the area on the FE Civil structural engineering practice problems page, or keep going with the beam deflection problems and reinforced concrete beam problems. To see these topics mixed with the other 13 areas, take the free FE Civil practice exam, or browse every topic in the free FE Civil practice problems hub.